Skip to content

SEO Test: Do Social Signals Matter?

Sara Taher
4 min read
SEO Test: Do Social Signals Matter?

There are 3 things if you talk about in the SEO world, not many people will like to listen:

  1. Social signals (traffic to website from a social platform and engagement on website URLs on social media)
  2. Unlinked brand mentions
  3. Non-clickable links

But do these things actually impact ranking? I decided to run an SEO experiment to test that out for myself.

TL;DR: Jump to Conclusion


In 2014, when I started learning about SEO, I remember one time running a Facebook Ad to get traffic to a specific blog article on my website. As the campaign started running and I was getting thousands of clicks, I saw an increase in rankings in GSC. The movement was similar to a bell curve.

Social signals in 2014
Social signals in 2014

And maybe back in the day it made sense to Google if a URL is getting plenty of attention on social media, then that means its a "valuable URL"... Also note how the algorithm didn't make steep changes in rankings.

John Muller 2022

In an Google SEO office hours, an SEO was asking about indexation issues his website was facing and John Muller replied suggesting 3 things:

  1. Not to use the site: operator as a diagnostic tool (a topic for another day)
  2. Check the technical side of things first to make sure there are no crawling or indexing issues
  3. Bombshell: promote your website by buying ads for example.

Why is this a bombshell? because does this mean social signals impact a website's indexing? (short answer: yes they do)

SEO Testing

Post Engagement on Twitter
Post Engagement on Twitter

So, I chose a fairly popular URL on my website that has attracted plenty of engagement and traffic already from Twitter and decided to run a Facebook ad campaign for 3 days with a $100 budget.

Facebook Campaign to Get Traffic to the Blog Post
Facebook Campaign to Get Traffic to the Blog Post

Did this impact rankings?


What about indexing? Do social signals impact indexing?

Going back to what John Muller mentioned above. I collected this data off my website. I compared publishing data against the date the URL started getting its first impression in GSC, here's how the data looks like for the last 10 articles published on my website:

How long does it take for a blog on my website to get impressions
How long does it take for a blog on my website to get impressions

Few things to note:

  • My website has 30 pages indexed in total (not all of these are blogs).
  • My website is a new website (launched August 2022) in a competitive industry.
  • The only advantage I have, is a strong personal brand on LinkedIn.
  • The last URL (no. 10) got plenty of social signals on twitter and yet took the longer than any other URL to get impressions.
  • For URL no.2, the data looks like that because of the time difference.

Control Website

  • Like any good experiment, you need control data. Luckily I have launched a test website to try things around the same time I launched my personal website and using the same CMS (
  • On this test website I have around 40 blogs.
  • I have built only 1 backlink and the website has NO social signals.

Here's the data from the control website:

  • As you can see, the pages are taking so long to get indexed, as there are no external efforts done to promote the website.


Social signals are one of the things that impact the speed at which your pages get indexed. But they have little value for improving ranking. 

From the data above, I'd say having a strong social presence gives your website an extra push in terms of URLs getting indexed but not in rankings.

Also, because of the last URL on the list, I'd say there's more that needs to be looked into. The data definitely does support what John Muller said.

There's a striking difference between the speed at which pages on my website get indexed vs. pages on my test website.

Another important conclusion is that, the results align with Google's E-E-A-T signals intended to display the most reliable informative results in SERPs, and therefore being popular on social media does not necessarily mean a page is a reliable source of data and deserves a higher spot in SERPs.


Related Posts

Members Public

How to Audit and Optimize Your Website for Interaction to Next Paint (INP)

Google announced recently that interaction to next paint is going to replace the FID metric in core web vitals starting March 2024. First Input Delay (FID) measures how long it takes for a website to respond to a user's first interaction. For example, the user lands on your webpage, and

How to Audit and Optimize Your Website for Interaction to Next Paint (INP)
Members Public

SEO Content Strategy

This newsletter is sponsored by AlsoAsked helps you find all “People Also Ask” data that appear in Google search results and saves you plenty of valuable time! I've talked about how and why you should do a content audit before and got plenty of feedback on that post.

SEO content strategy
Members Public

SEO in the Age of AI: Why you're not losing your job anytime soon

Will SEO become (is becoming) obsolete? There's some anticipation in the SEO industry about how SEO will look like with many search engines now adding "answer bots" similar to chatGPT. TL;DR: Jump to the Conclusion The best way to predict the future is to look at the data we

This image was generated by Canva Text to Image AI tool